Traitor’s Gate

My posting of a version of my last blog here on the LRB blogsite ruffled some feathers. Immediately a couple of anti-Corbynists leapt in with comments which didn’t begin to address my argument, but simply bad-mouthed JC. He is a ‘coward’, an ‘opportunist’, ‘wishing the worst for the UK’. ‘I’m not even sure why we are debating this,’ wrote one dyspeptic correspondent; ‘in better times under Churchill etc, the bearded wonder and his sinister henchman McDonnell would be residing in the Tower on a diet of bread and water. Traitors will always be traitors.’ – I thought that kind of talk had gone out with the Goon Show.

All these comments were offered over pseudonyms; a practice I deplore, and have railed against in earlier blogs (here’s one: I sometimes wonder about the depth of the hostility shown towards this apparently pretty good man. In some ways it resembles the animus against Obama in America, another good man, however much you might disagree with him. I also, these days, wonder whether the pseudonyms might be concealing something else: the Israeli government agencies, for example, which we know for sure are trying to undermine Corbyn subvertly – because of his defence of the Palestinians. I doubt it, in these cases; but those who write over (or under) pseudonyms must be aware that the practice could arouse this kind of suspicion. It’s better to be open and upfront, willing to own your opinions, never to cower behind aliases. (Unless of course openness puts you in danger; for example of losing your job.)

There were some more reasoned and reasonable objections to my argument. But it also occurs to me, as I suggested in the course of that rather dispiriting exchange on the LRB Blog, that the nub of the matter may be simply the importance one attaches  to the Brexit issue. To me, and to most of those who read the LRB, it must seem pretty vital; affecting as it does our very feeling of identity and the character of our country. In a nutshell, it’s existential. (My application for Swedish citizenship is in order to escape from it. That’s how strongly I feel.) But for the mass of people, and in the long term, it really matters very little. They didn’t really vote, in that notorious referendum, on the issue of Europe, about which they had shown little sign of caring before then. That was an ‘elite’ thing, on both sides. The fundamental problems with Britain, which fuelled the ‘out’ vote, ran much deeper: to do with austerity, late-stage capitalism, inequality, the democratic deficit, the north-south divide, and much more. The European issue didn’t directly affect these, though there can be arguments on both sides over which position – in or out – will marginally help to cure these basic woes. It seems more likely, however, that the main significance of the European issue in this broader context was, and is, to act as a distraction from these profounder problems; in which case Corbyn’s ambivalent stance towards the Brexit issue makes sense, and the higher priority Labour is putting on securing a General Election could be wise.

About bernardporter2013

Retired academic, author, historian.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Traitor’s Gate

  1. TJ says:

    It’a Labour’s responsibility to hold the Tories not to collude with them in a Brexit deal that is to the comparative disadvantage of the country. Having exhausted all parliamentary means, and with May probably getting some kind of deal through so Corbyn has to play a longer game and make the Tories own the full consequences of Brexit, and dangle on the gibbet of their own making. Labour can meanwhile address the fears and concerns that were, as Bernard says, behind a lot of Brexit discontent and votes.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Krzys Stankiewicz says:

    Bernard – Happy New Year from a Brit in NW Poland! I always enjoy your ‘Pensees’, even though I may not always agree with them. Just one point to make here if I may. In your List of ‘Brexit Grievances’ – with which I concur – one very vital thing is missing, and that’s Immigration, specifically of EU Nationals into the UK (though I know many people voted Leave because they thought it would stop Black People and Muslims coming in as well). During the Referendum my Polish wife Ania and I were living in Bolton – strong UKIP and odious English Defence League territory, which voted 63% Leave. Nigel Farage visited twice and was feted and regaled. Once I was walking in the main Town Hall square and chatting in Polish with Ania, when an EDL thug accosted me and said aggressively ‘When are you going back?’ Knees knocking, but trying to keep my voice calm I replied ‘I was never there in the first place!’ (I’m Manchester born and bred, 66 years old, and only moved to the Land of My Ancestors 13 months ago) This threw him a bit, so, slightly emboldened, i pressed on with ‘I’m as British as you are – just happen to speak another language apart from English’. Slowly he turned and walked away. I sat down and let my knees knock freely… Let no-one underestimate the hostility towards ‘The Polish’ and other EU Nationals. It drove and overwhelmed the Referendum and I fear will do so again if put to the test as that particular poison has seeped down very deeply into British soil

    Liked by 1 person

  3. You deserve to be pleased with, rather than dismayed by the LRB readers’ response to your Corbyn post. A number of important issues were canvassed in a spirited manner. I liked the way you were prepared to take on your critics rather than stand back from the fray.
    Corbyn’s support among Labour members is being weakened by his refusal to back a second referendum, which has overwhelming support on the left. It will be disappointing if Corbyn’s social democratic agenda for the UK is destroyed because of his equivocation on the importance of EU membership.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s