I won’t have been the first to notice how rational political discussion these days has been replaced by slogans, usually consisting of just three words. ‘Get Brexit Done’ seems to have won the last General Election for Boris; following on from ‘Take Back Control’. These proved more effective than – in the previous election – Teresa May’s ‘Brexit Means Brexit’, which was a bit of a cheat, because it was only two words really; and ‘Strong and Stable’, which was pleasantly alliterative, but sounded unconvincing in the light of her obvious weakness and recent change of mind on Brexit. (It may also have reminded senior voters of the old toilet-paper ad: ‘Soft, Strong and Soluble’, which won’t have helped.) Now the government is seeking to repeat this winning tripartite formula with its simple posted injunctions at its Coronovirus press conferences: ‘Stay Home. Protect the NHS. Save Lives’. (Currently. They vary it.) Other simplistic formulations that seem to have hit the spot in recent years are ‘Project Fear’, to demonise the pro-EU cause, before it turned into ‘Project Reality’; and – reducing it now to a single word – ‘Sovereignty’. In an age of banner headlines, advertising slogans and ‘sound-bites’, and with an electorate largely uneducated for its democratic role, this seems to have been a winning strategy. More subtle, intelligent and developed appeals – such as Corbyn’s compromise Brexit policy, the virtues of which we can all, surely, see today – stood no chance. The ‘sloganising’ way of dismissing that was as ‘indecisive’. Labour and the pro-EU side, it appears, had no answer to this.
I’m sure the Left and ‘Rejoiners’ could come up with some pithy slogans of their own, if they only put their minds to it. ‘For the Many, Not the Few’ was a good stab at it, which seems to have resonated amongst the young in the 2017 General Election – the one that May nearly lost. ‘Take Back Control’, recycled, might even work now for Remainers, seeing how much ‘control’ Brexit has taken from us. (OK, probably too confusing.) I can think of negative ones to use against Johnson – ‘Delay, Dither, Panic’ comes to mind immediately for those coronavirus press conferences; and we could of course focus on the government’s blatant incompetence and corruption. ‘People Before Profit’ might work again. But we need something more original, positive and pro-European, in order to motivate people in the same way that the idea of ‘Taking Back Control’ did. I’m sure that the Labour Party and the Rejoin Europe movement will receive any suggestions gratefully.
Of course this is not new. Some of us will remember ‘You’ve Never Had it So Good’; and ‘Life’s better under the Conservatives; don’t let Labour ruin it’…. and so on, back to the time of Disraeli and Gladstone, if not before. (And I’ve just remembered my school motto in the ’fifties: ‘Virtue. Learning. Manners’. Obviously not Eton’s; not in that order, anyway.) All of which doesn’t however detract from the necessity of trying to combat this strategy in the present, and with counter-slogans if necessary; however painful that might be to those of us who would prefer more extended and rational forms of debate.
At its worse sloganizing can be seriously misleading, as in the Brexit referendum campaign where they substituted lies for truth. The right wing press then perpetuate these ad nauseum until they take on a kind of mythical validity of their own, confirming existing prejudices. They become almost impossible to invalidate, even with statistical evidence or through experience (eg Brexit consequences). The anti-European slogans will continue ad nauseum as the consequences of Brexit become increasingly awful..
LikeLiked by 3 people
I remember learning, briefly, about propaganda while at school in the early 60s. We were actually looking at the use of it by a certain party in Europe in the 1930s, but leave that…
Two points stayed with me: 1) if you’re going to tell a lie, tell a big one, and 2) once you’ve told a lie, keep telling it – more and more people will believe it.
LikeLiked by 2 people
The 1930s reference is exactly right. I’m sure that Dominic Cummings’s fabled magic was based on Goebbels.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Perhaps one of the most successful – and memorable – slogans came from across the Channel over 200 years ago: ‘Liberté – Egalité – Fraternité!’ Then there’s ‘Bread and Circuses’, going even further back (if that was ever a ‘slogan’). As for the present, ‘Community Needs Unity’ sounds OK, but I’m not sure it really works. ‘Better Together’ didn’t, did it?
LikeLiked by 2 people
Also “Peace, Land and Bread”, a slogan, which was very effective from July to October, 1917, in communicating the Bolshevik wish list. The slogan is doubly effective, in that students learning about that era a century later have a simple mnemonic device for recalling Lenin’s program – together with “All power to the Soviets”, which Lenin never believed, while continuing to pretend that he did.
LikeLiked by 1 person